When I Stopped Pretending

We visited a new church a couple weeks ago.

And the sermon felt… uncomfortably close to home.

The pastor talked about how so many of us are pretending.

Especially now—when it’s so easy to curate a life online.

We post the best photos. Share the most meaningful thoughts.
We present a version of ourselves that feels acceptable.

But underneath it all, there’s often a quieter truth:

We’re tired.
We’re hurting.
We’re carrying things we don’t know how to name out loud.

And the more we pretend, the more alone we become.

That part stayed with me.

Because I know what it feels like to live behind a mask.

And I also know what it costs to take it off.


A few years ago, my life broke open in ways I never expected.

Grief. Loss. Questions I didn’t have answers for.
Pain that didn’t resolve neatly.
Faith that didn’t feel steady or certain.

And somewhere in the middle of all of that…
I stopped pretending.

Not in a rebellious way.

And maybe, from the outside, it looked dramatic.

But from the inside… it felt necessary.

I couldn’t keep smiling and saying “I’m okay” when I wasn’t.
I couldn’t keep packaging my life into something easier for others to understand.
I couldn’t keep performing a version of faith that didn’t match what I was actually living.

So I told the truth.

I was hurting.
I was confused.
I was questioning things I had always believed.

And what I didn’t expect…
was how uncomfortable that made people.


It turns out, people are often more comfortable with your pretend version than your real one.

The version of you that is healing nicely.
That has the right words.
That wraps pain in something hopeful and easy to digest.

But raw grief?
Ongoing struggle?
Faith that doesn’t tie up neatly?

That’s harder for people to sit with.

Some didn’t know what to say.
Some pulled back.
Some tried to fix it quickly.
And some just… couldn’t handle it at all.

And I don’t say that with bitterness.

I think many of us were taught the same thing:

That brokenness should be hidden.
That faith should look strong.
That struggles should be temporary and quietly resolved.

But this sermon—the message—challenged that in a way I needed.


The pastor spoke about Paul.
About the “thorn” he carried.

Something painful. Persistent. Unresolved.

Paul begged God to take it away.

And God didn’t.

Instead, He said:

“My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.”

I’ve heard that verse before.

But this time, it felt different.

Because it wasn’t presented as a neat, comforting answer.

It was honest.

God didn’t promise to remove the pain.
He promised to be present within it.


And if I’m being honest…
that’s the kind of faith I’m learning to live in now.

Not the kind that pretends everything is okay.
Not the kind that hides the hard parts.

But the kind that says:

This is where I am.
This is what I’m carrying.
And I’m still here.


I think about how Paul chose to boast in his weakness.

Not because he enjoyed suffering.
But because it meant he didn’t have to pretend anymore.

There’s something freeing about that.

And also something terrifying.

Because when you stop pretending, you risk being misunderstood.
You risk people stepping back.
You risk not fitting into the spaces you once did.

I’ve felt that.

But I’ve also felt something else:

Relief.


Relief in not having to perform.
Relief in being honest.
Relief in letting my story be what it actually is—messy, unfinished, still unfolding.

And maybe that’s what I’m holding onto right now:

That I don’t have to be fully healed to be worthy of connection.
That I don’t have to have answers to belong.
That my “thorn”—whatever shape it takes—doesn’t disqualify me.


If anything, it might be the very place where I’m met most deeply.

Not by people who need me to be okay.

But by those who are willing to sit in the real with me.

And maybe… by God, too.


If you’re reading this and you’ve been pretending—
holding it together, saying the right things, hiding what hurts—

I just want you to know:

You’re not alone.

And you don’t have to clean yourself up to be seen.

Your brokenness doesn’t make you less worthy.
It makes you human.

And maybe, just maybe…
it’s the place where something real can finally begin.


Discover more from Amanda Warrior Princess

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

This Post Has One Comment

  1. Steve Holmes

    Not the first time I’ve heard of people trying to squeeze others into an acceptable box. I just glad you resisted.

Leave a Reply